Pundit_Sidebar

March 16, 2007

Valerie Plame Stands Tall (Brent Budowsky)

@ 1:19 pm

First. I spent a number of years of my life working on the Intelligence Identities Protection Act with its original sponsor, then-Sen. Lloyd Bentsen.

Second. It should now be clear even to the most rabid partisan apologist for Bush administration wrongdoing that Valerie Plame was a covert operative, that her identity and status were classified, and that she had performed abroad within the last five years.

Third. I know and admire Valerie Plame and consider her an American hero, an American patriot, and an invaluable national resource in defeating global terrorism who has been compromised by shameless and despicable acts, by partisans and ideologues.

The president of the United States owes Valerie Plame and every covert officer a profound apology.

The president of the United States owes the vice president and Karl Rove an aggressive, severe, and public reprimand, at a minimum.

The president of the United States owes the American people, our covert officers and the rule of law an ironclad commitment that he will not issue a pardon to anyone convicted in this case.

Having been involved in writing this law for so long, I have, unlike some others, avoided comment on legal guilt or innocence and have avoided any public discussion that could have even remotely reached or influenced the jurors in this case.

When The Washington Post ran thousands of words on its editorial page, its opinion page, its “Outlook” section and even its “Style” section in the hours before the case went before the jury, and I was offered a modest 170 words representing so many not taking the pro-Libby position, even then I avoided discussion of guilt or innocence to make the larger point.

The words in this note, which will ultimately be read by many covert officers of the United States, represent the views of the vast and overwhelming majority of covert officers who cannot speak for themselves.

The central point is this, setting aside the evidentiary issues surrounding the case before the courts:

I am proud of Valerie Plame; I am proud of every man and woman serving our country covertly. I am as proud of them as I am proud of everyone who serves in the United States Marine Corps, the United States Army, the United States Navy, the United States Air Force, the Coast Guard, our National Guard, our Reserves and our astronaut corps.

One Republican congressman said today at the hearing that well, this is the problem of the CIA, not the White House.

This is dead wrong. This is what has gone so wrong with George W. Bush, with the vice president, with distortions and attacks surrounding our intelligence, with mistreatment of wounded troops that should never occur in our country, and with the identity disclosures in this case which, whatever the legal niceties, are despicable and damaging to our security.

I ask the congressman, the president, the vice president and the apologists for this travesty: How would you feel if someone stood at the back of a United States Marine at the center of Baghdad, and pointed to him for an enemy sniper to kill?

This is not the problem of the CIA. It is the problem of all of us, in the same way that mistreatment of our wounded troops is not merely the problem of military families, but the problem of all of us.

In America we are all security moms and security dads. We are all in the band of brothers and sisters who serve our country. We are all in this together. We are all part of the American family that owes them all, everything they need and deserve to defend us.

In service all give some, some give all, and those at home owe every one of them our best.

We owe it to the Marines, the Army, the Navy, the Air Force, the Coast Guard, the National Guard, the Reserves and the astronauts — and we damn well owe it to the men and women who serve with incredible courage and valor in our clandestine service.

What the president and vice president have never understood, what the apologists and flacks and hacks and partisans and “oppo” players and smear artists have never understood, is this: To protect our men and women who serve covertly is a sacred trust, written in blood, sanctified by oath, etched in stone, that should be seared into our souls with honor.

We are not asked to demonstrate their courage, but we are expected to watch their backs, and not risk their lives, as though they are the petty cash of our partisan politics, or the disposable commodities of our blind ideologies or vainglorious ambitions.

I will leave it to the judges and juries to determine guilt or innocence.

But make no mistake, these disclosures were the sickening and disgusting result of partisan players who risked the lives of heroes, from their safe perches of official power.

There are heroes behind enemy lines, while cowards hatch their plans dining in fine restaurants, gabbing on their BlackBerrys and writing their talking points of slander and smear.

These disclosures violate the timeless code of honor that belongs to every man and women of every clandestine service, in all democratic nations, in every corner of the world.

This code of honor belongs to every man and woman of the CIA, of MI-6, of the Mossad; and every other service that defends our freedom and protects our communities from terror.

Like the health of our wounded troops, this code of honor belongs to every man and woman in our land. It is the sacred trust of every institution in our government, which even the most sick and demented partisan, in the darkest corners of this capital, should protect with their honor, and if necessary, with their lives.

Those who wear our uniform are America’s heroes. Those who serve covertly are America’s heroes. Those who risk and give their lives and limbs are America’s heroes. And those who betray their trust, for foreign enemies or domestic politics, deserve the condemnation of American patriots everywhere.

Archived under: Uncategorized
Permalink TrackBack EMail This Post


Share this post
del.icio.us:Valerie Plame Stands Tall digg:Valerie Plame Stands Tall newsvine:Valerie Plame Stands Tall reddit:Valerie Plame Stands Tall fark:Valerie Plame Stands Tall Y!:Valerie Plame Stands Tall What's This



12 Comments »

The Hill welcomes comment from anyone and will almost always post it whether it is favorable or critical, as long as it is substantive and advances debate.

  1. Thanks for this excellent, inspiring writing.

    I do condemn the traitors that have hijacked many this country's highest offices. May they someday be served justice by a restored US justice system.

    Comment by klevenstein — March 16, 2007 @ 2:38 pm

  2. Amen to the call for an apology. Excellent post.

    Comment by News Grinder — March 16, 2007 @ 2:59 pm

  3. This is hoping that this is just the warm up to the rest of the scandals that are still buried deeply. Maybe we won't have to wait another 20 months for this monster and his cabal to leave the WH. Maybe they'll all fly off to Paraguay and give us our country back. I'm mad as hell and I don't want to put up with this anymore. It's time for them all to go. There is a special place in hell for these people. My 5 cents worth…

    Comment by Nina — March 16, 2007 @ 3:41 pm

  4. I agree with your point about the treachery of the leakers of Valerie Plame's identity.
    But your peon to the alleged heroism to all the agents and soldiers of the US (and Israel) is deeply offensive, for the simple reason that many of them have committed gross violations of human rights by simply taking part in US (or Israeli) foreign policy, even if individually they appear "honorable". Remember Iraq and Lebanon? Or American empire in the 20th century? Apparently not.

    Comment by Jeffrey Briggs — March 16, 2007 @ 3:50 pm

  5. Extremely well written, I couldn't agree more.

    Comment by Derek D. — March 16, 2007 @ 5:57 pm

  6. Well said Brent. I am at once elated that we are finally seeing some oversight, and depressed that the media is doing a horrible job (with a few exceptions) in reporting today's hearing.

    I want to know why the president LIED and said this will be investigated yet today we learn that in fact never happened. (according to James Knodell)

    Comment by kimoco — March 16, 2007 @ 8:20 pm

  7. No one could have said it better.

    I don't know whether to cheer or cry. You spelled it out
    exactly how this has gone down,
    beautifully written this sad
    chain of events that the president and vice president
    refuse to acknowledge.
    All should be brought to justice.

    Comment by Angela — March 16, 2007 @ 8:35 pm

  8. Nice article Mr. Budowsky —
    But what does it have to do with the fact that no one was arrested, indicted, tried or convicted of outing Ms. Plame?
    Libby was convicted of the same crimes that former President Clinton was impeached for. As much as liberals like you want to somw how make Libby's conviction evidence that the Bush administration outed Ms. Plame, there still is no evidence it did. Even Valerie Plame's testimony itself doesn't prove it.
    The person who actually outed Valerie Plame, the person who made her name public, was Robert Novak. Of course he won't even be reprimanded because he, as a reporter, can claim Constitutional protection.

    Comment by Laurence Socci — March 17, 2007 @ 8:08 am

  9. Thank you for truth and facts. I was very upset today when our paper quoted a paper that said again that Valerie was not covert. She said under oath that she was out of the US in the last5yrs.I wish you could send your article to the Decatur Herald in Decatur Ill.
    Thanks again. ZLD in ILLINOIS

    Comment by Zola Daniels — March 17, 2007 @ 9:22 am

  10. It is amazing that a President would out a covert CIA agent and not face trial for treason. Someone owes Ms. Plame an apology but you will never here it from this horrendously corrupt cabal. Lies come easily to this Administration, and deception is only a game. They know no remorse.

    Comment by Chris in NM — March 17, 2007 @ 2:27 pm

  11. Well done. However, don't count on having Bush apologize. It 's a word he has not learned in school and therefore doesnt know its meaning.

    Comment by Andrushka — March 18, 2007 @ 9:22 am

  12. The time spent by Congress and the press agonizing over the revelation of CIA operative Valerie Plame’s identity is a pitiful waste of taxpayers’ money and airtime. Why has no one asked the REASON & MOTIVE certain government officials may have compromised her cover? To get back at her husband’s (Joseph C. Wilson IV) criticism of the Administration’s Iraq war decision is in no way a plausible reason. In what context did they name her? Did they ASK the press to publicize her name? If Robert Novak received such information, why did he feel obliged to publish it in his response to Wilson on 7/14/2003? His motive clearly was to discredit Joseph Wilson, but Novak does not work for the Administration. Does Novak have no respect for national security? Has he forgotten the old axiom “loose lips sink ships”? I think he should be taken to task and prosecuted for making public such information. However, the press is never wrong and rarely culpable! In many instances, it is the press who have put our fighting men & women in danger in Iraq and Afghanistan, by publishing sensitive information, useful to the enemy. FDR was right to gag the press during WWII in many respects. If GW were more popular, he could and should do likewise. Freedom of the press is a precious right, but it does not mean that we should harm innocent people in the process of exercising this right, especially during wartime.

    3/18/2007

    Comment by Lewis F Clark — March 18, 2007 @ 11:02 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions
rss

The contents of this site are © 2008 Capitol Hill Publishing Corp., a subsidiary of News Communications Inc.